An argumentative essay: The Doctor is Right to Use Force

Published under category: Academic Paper Writing | 2015-05-05 07:35:55 UTC

Context: Argumentative papers

The use of force in this story is justifiable as the doctor wants to save the life of the young girl. The young girl, Mathilda, is ignorant of the danger that the illness poses to her and tries to resist every attempt of the doctor’s actions for the purposes of saving her life. The doctor feels compelled by social necessity hence he acts with force in order to discover whether the child has a sore throat or not. The story clearly demonstrates that the doctor is good natured and sets out to help Mathilda overcome her sickness. The doctor understands what the family is going through as is reflected in his statement where he says that he had witnessed two kids die from diphtheria as a result of neglect. This reveals that the doctor was prepared to go at all lengths to help the child recover from the diphtheria that she was suffering from for the sake of her parents. The doctor is also determined to provide treatment for the sake of the young girl. The girl has a sore throat but was not willing to talk or to open her mouth to anyone, including the doctor. The girl acts stubbornly and is very terrified of the doctor. The doctor is compelled to use force although he finds it a little difficult to separate his emotions and the standards that he has set for himself. In order to lessen the conflict that was apparent from the time he entered the Olsons’ house, the doctor initially acts very professionally by making a decision to adopt a more standard way to approach the child. In the story, the doctor mentions that he smiled in his best professional manner, and also attempted to coax the young girl. Mathilda, however, was not welcoming to the doctor’s advances as she acted in a very unfriendly manner. The doctor mentions that the girl face was expressionless and his attempts to talk to her futile as the little girl did not respond to him. The young girl became more reluctant with every doctor’s move, and even became more and more defensive. The manner in which the child was behaving made the doctor lose control of his emotions and he became furious hence resorted to the application of force to diagnose the disease that affected the child. The wooden tongue depressor that is used by the doctor represents some kind of metaphor that indicates the tolerance of the doctor. When the child grips the depressor with her teeth and it breaks into splinters, the doctor’s level of patience also reaches a breaking point. The doctor, therefore, shuns rationality and resorts to force. The use of force by the doctor in this case is for a good purpose. The doctor has developed a liking for the young girl despite her stubbornness. The doctor liked Mathilda due to her beauty, the magnificent blonde hair, which even prompted the doctor to compare her to the picture-children who featured in an advertisement and photogravure parts in the Sunday papers. The doctor is also impressed by the determination of the young girl to defend herself against him. The doctor has been impressed by the girl both by her beauty and determination and, therefore, develops an obligation to save the girl’s life by curing her off diphtheria. He felt that he needed to help her even if it involved the use of physical force. Professionally, the doctor’s duty involves treating his patients to relieve them from suffering caused by ailments. Mathilda is not aware of the danger she is faced with when suffering from diphtheria. The doctor goes ahead to mention about the death of two children who had died because of the disease. The death of the children was as a result of neglect. They had not been treated in good time. The doctor, therefore, wanted to push for the diagnosis in order to discover the ailment Mathilda had and provide treatment as soon as possible. The treatment of Mathilda is more urgent because of the neglect displayed by the Olsons, who tried to treat the child using other means that have failed. Mathilda has had the sickness for three days already. The doctor feels that giving Mathilda time to calm down is dangerous. This feeling is displayed when the doctor mentions that he ought to have left and come back after one hour or more. The doctor is driven by a sense of urgency to use force in order to save Mathilda’s life. The Olsons do not aid the doctor in administering treatment to the young girl. The doctor feels annoyed by the comments they make when he tries to coax the child to open her mouth. Mathilda’s mother tries to calm down Mathilda by telling her to cooperate with the doctor since the doctor will not hurt her. The doctor feels the use of the word “hurt” makes Mathilda to be more uncooperative. When Mathilda sends the doctor’s glasses flying to the floor, the parents are embarrassed and rebuke Mathilda for being violent to a nice man. The doctor is not impressed by being referred to as a nice man. He feels his duty is to treat the child rather than to be a nice man. The doctor feels the parents have cultivated a feeling in their child that the treatment is going to be painful. The doctor is forced to order the father to place the child on his laps and hold her wrists. The doctor mentions that when he was almost succeeding with opening the Mathilda’s mouth, the father would let go of her because of the fear of hurting her. The doctor is, therefore, compelled to use more force on the girl. The doctor cared about Mathilda’s parents’ feelings towards their girl. He felt that the parents’ love for their child had compelled them to spend three dollars for his visit to diagnose and treat the child. The doctor, therefore, felt that it was his duty to treat the child at all costs. The concern of the parents is reflected when the doctor comes into the house. The doctor reports that all of them were nervous. The parents display a sense of frustration when they mention to the doctor that they have tried all the other means of treatment, but they had failed. The doctor is their last hope in the treatment of their daughter. The doctor knows this fact and, therefore, does not want to let them down. When the child refuses to cooperate, he is forced to use force in order to relieve the parents off their agony of seeing their daughter suffer. The act of the doctor in his efforts to treat Mathilda may be viewed by others as professionally wrong. However, the benefits of the doctor using force far outweigh the harm that he might have caused at that time. The doctor is right in using force to treat Mathilda. ORDER PLAGIARISM FREE PAPER


Post a comment

You can order a custom written paper

We accept all kinds of custom papers and we do not turn our customers away. Academic papers urgently needed are welcome

Support reviews all essays and academic papers to make sure general requirements such as grammar and format are followed

Students ranging from highschool to Doctoral level can have their essays and custom academic papers done here